Optimizing the management of patients with small renal masses in a Canadian context: A Markov decision-analysis model

Authors

  • Kristen McAlpine
  • Maneesh Sud
  • Antonio Finelli
  • Girish S. Kulkarni

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.5489/cuaj.7301

Keywords:

biopsy, decision analysis, kidney cancer

Abstract

Introduction: The management of patients with a small renal mass (SRM) varies significantly. The objective of this study was to determine which initial management strategy resulted in the greatest quality- adjusted life months (QALM) for an index patient with a SRM.

Methods: A Markov decision analysis was used to determine the effect of 1) treating patients with a partial nephrectomy (PN); 2) active surveillance (AS); and 3) renal mass biopsy on QALM over a 10-year horizon. All relevant health states were modelled. Biopsy sensitivity and specificity were modelled assuming an 80% prevalence of cancer using procedural pathology as the gold standard. Health state utilities were obtained from the Tufts Medical Centre Cost-Effective Analysis Registry. Deterministic sensitivity analyses were used to test key assumptions.

Results: Over a 10-year time horizon for a 70-year-old male with a 2 cm SRM, the biopsy strategy resulted in 38.07 QALM, whereas treating all patients with PN resulted in 37.69 QALM and AS in 36.25 QALM. The model was most sensitive to the probability that a patient would remain alive at baseline. Biopsy was the preferred strategy when sensitivity was greater than 77%. As the underlying probability of cancer increased, the threshold of renal mass biopsy sensitivity to still favor biopsy increased.

Conclusions: Renal mass biopsy is the preferred initial management strategy for an index patient with a SRM to optimize QALM. When the probability of cancer is high, centers should aim for a sensitivity of at least 77% in order to consider a biopsy as the first strategy.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Downloads

Published

2021-08-26

How to Cite

McAlpine, K., Sud, M., Finelli, A., & Kulkarni, G. S. (2021). Optimizing the management of patients with small renal masses in a Canadian context: A Markov decision-analysis model. Canadian Urological Association Journal, 16(1), E32–8. https://doi.org/10.5489/cuaj.7301

Issue

Vol. 16 No. 1 (2022): CUAJ January

Section

Original Research

License

You, the Author(s), assign your copyright in and to the Article to the Canadian Urological Association. This means that you may not, without the prior written permission of the CUA:

  • Post the Article on any Web site
  • Translate or authorize a translation of the Article
  • Copy or otherwise reproduce the Article, in any format, beyond what is permitted under Canadian copyright law, or authorize others to do so
  • Copy or otherwise reproduce portions of the Article, including tables and figures, beyond what is permitted under Canadian copyright law, or authorize others to do so.

The CUA encourages use for non-commercial educational purposes and will not unreasonably deny any such permission request.

You retain your moral rights in and to the Article. This means that the CUA may not assert its copyright in such a way that would negatively reflect on your reputation or your right to be associated with the Article.

The CUA also requires you to warrant the following:

  • That you are the Author(s) and sole owner(s), that the Article is original and unpublished and that you have not previously assigned copyright or granted a licence to any other third party;
  • That all individuals who have made a substantive contribution to the article are acknowledged;
  • That the Article does not infringe any proprietary right of any third party and that you have received the permissions necessary to include the work of others in the Article; and
  • That the Article does not libel or violate the privacy rights of any third party.