Development, implementation, and evaluation of a competency-based didactic and simulation-focused boot camp for incoming urology residents: Report of the first three years

  • Yuding Wang
  • Jen Hoogenes McMaster University
  • Roderick Clark
  • Nathan C. Wong
  • Udi Blankstein
  • Harkanwal Randhawa
  • Catherine Lovatt
  • Kevin Kim
  • Noah Stern
  • Jeffrey Law
  • Samir Sami
  • Michael Uy
  • Courtney Moore
  • Bobby Shayegan
  • Anil Kapoor
  • Shahid Lambe
  • Timothy Davies
  • Sumit Dave
  • Alp Sener
  • Edward D. Matsumoto
Keywords: urology, resident, competency, curriculum, boot camp

Abstract

Introduction: The Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada’s Competence by Design (CBD) initiative presents curricula challenges to ensure residents gain proficiency while progressing through training. To prepare first-year urology residents (R1s), we developed, implemented, and evaluated a didactic and simulation-focused boot camp to implement the CBD curriculum. We report our experiences and findings of the first three years.

Methods: Urology residents from two Canadian universities participated in the two-day boot camp at the beginning of residency. Eleven didactic and six simulation sessions allowed for instruction and deliberate practice with feedback. Pre-and post-course multiple-choice questionnaires (MCQs) and an objective structured clinical exam (OSCE) evaluated knowledge and skills uptake. For initial program evaluation, three R2s served as historical controls in year 1.

Results: Nineteen residents completed boot camp. The mean age was 26.4 (±2.8) and 13 were male. Participants markedly improved on the pre- and post-MCQs (year 1: 62% and 91%; year 2: 55% and 89%; year 3: 58% and 86%, respectively). Participants scored marginally higher than the controls on four of the six OSCE stations. OSCE scores remained >88% over the three cohorts. All participants reported higher confidence levels post-boot camp and felt it was excellent preparation for residency.

Conclusions: During its first three years, our urology boot camp has demonstrated high feasibility and utility. Knowledge and technical skills uptake were established via MCQ and OSCE results, with participants’ scores near or above those of R2 controls. This boot camp will remain in our CBD curriculum and can provide a framework for other urology residency programs.

Author Biography

Jen Hoogenes, McMaster University

Jen Hoogenes, MS, MSc, PhD

Research Fellow and Clinical Research Coordinator III, McMaster University Department of Surgery, Division of Urology

Published
2020-09-28
How to Cite
Wang, Y., Hoogenes, J., Clark, R., Wong, N. C., Blankstein, U., Randhawa, H., Lovatt, C., Kim, K., Stern, N., Law, J., Sami, S., Uy, M., Moore, C., Shayegan, B., Kapoor, A., Lambe, S., Davies , T., Dave, S., Sener, A., & Matsumoto, E. D. (2020). Development, implementation, and evaluation of a competency-based didactic and simulation-focused boot camp for incoming urology residents: Report of the first three years. Canadian Urological Association Journal, 15(4), 98-105. https://doi.org/10.5489/cuaj.6679
Section
Original Research